Revisiting Humanitarian Knowledge: A Poststructural Analysis of DG ECHO’s 2025 Humanitarian Implementation Plane for Ukraine and Moldova
Translated title
Revisiting Humanitarian Knowledge
Author
Campolo, Carmine
Term
4. semester
Education
Publication year
2026
Submitted on
2026-10-15
Abstract
This thesis explores what DG ECHO’s 2025 Humanitarian Implementation Plan (HIP) for Ukraine and Moldova reveals about how humanitarian knowledge is formed and changes over time. Using a poststructuralist perspective, the study looks at knowledge through the categories, assumptions, and practices that are used to describe humanitarian situations and make intervention proposals understandable. The analysis applies Bacchi and Goodwin’s “What’s the Problem Represented to be?” (WPR) approach. It starts from the proposals in the HIP and works backwards to reconstruct how problems are represented, and to examine the types of knowledge and power relations involved. These findings are then discussed in relation to a historical dimension of humanitarian knowledge, reconstructed through the literature on humanitarianism. The analysis shows that “need” is a central reference point around which humanitarian knowledge in the HIP is organized. Economic, legal, and technical forms of knowledge help describe people’s conditions, while categories of need and vulnerability support the setting of priorities. Through the document’s institutional function, these priorities also shape the proposals put forward by partners seeking funding. In dialogue with the historical literature, the study identifies ongoing patterns in the growing specialization of knowledge and in the role of classifications and institutions in organizing humanitarian assistance. In the examined case, these elements mainly support assistance within existing conditions, without necessarily aiming to address the root causes of the crisis. While analyzing a single document cannot by itself prove long-term change in humanitarian knowledge, it shows how elements linked to historical transformations in humanitarianism can coexist with a stable practice of relief. The thesis thus contributes to understanding how humanitarian knowledge takes shape through the relationship between different types of knowledge, the goals of assistance, and institutional orientations.
Denne afhandling undersøger, hvad DG ECHOs Humanitarian Implementation Plan (HIP) for Ukraine og Moldova for 2025 kan fortælle os om, hvordan humanitær viden bliver til og forandres. Med udgangspunkt i et poststrukturalistisk perspektiv ser studiet på viden gennem de kategorier, antagelser og praksisser, der bruges til at beskrive humanitære situationer og gøre forslag til indsatser forståelige. Analysen anvender Bacchi og Goodwins tilgang “What’s the Problem Represented to be?” (WPR). Udgangspunktet er HIP-dokumentets forslag, og der arbejdes baglæns for at rekonstruere, hvordan problemerne fremstilles, og hvilke former for viden og magtrelationer der indgår. Resultaterne sættes derefter i forbindelse med en historisk dimension af humanitær viden, som er rekonstrueret gennem litteratur om humanitarisme. Analysen viser, at “behov” fungerer som et centralt omdrejningspunkt, som humanitær viden i HIP’en organiseres omkring. Økonomisk, juridisk og teknisk viden bidrager til at beskrive menneskers livssituation, mens kategorier for behov og sårbarhed hjælper med at udpege, hvem der skal prioriteres. Gennem dokumentets institutionelle rolle er disse prioriteringer også styrende for, hvilke forslag eksterne partnere udarbejder, når de søger finansiering. Sammenholdt med den historiske litteratur peger analysen på en fortsættelse af tendenser, hvor specialiseret viden, klassifikationer og institutioner strukturerer den humanitære indsats. I det undersøgte tilfælde understøtter disse elementer primært hjælp inden for de eksisterende rammer, uden nødvendigvis at sigte mod at ændre de grundlæggende årsager til krisen. Undersøgelsen af ét dokument kan ikke i sig selv påvise en langsigtet forandring i humanitær viden, men viser, hvordan elementer, der forbindes med historiske udviklinger i humanitarisme, kan sameksistere med en stabil praksis for nødhjælp. Studiet bidrager dermed til en bedre forståelse af, hvordan humanitær viden formes i spændingsfeltet mellem forskellige vidensformer, mål med hjælpen og institutionelle prioriteringer.
[This abstract has been rewritten with the help of AI based on the project's original abstract]
