A master thesis from Aalborg University
Slutbrugeraftalevilkår i Videospil: Et Ophavsretligt Perspektiv
[End User License Agreement Terms in Video Games in a Copyright Perspective]
Forfatter(e)
Semester
4. semester
Uddannelse
Udgivelsesår
2020
Afleveret
2020-05-19
Antal sider
76 pages
Abstract
When purchasing video games, most sellers require that the consumer agree to a so called end user license agreement (EULA), which specifies a number of terms and conditions between the two parties. Several of these terms relates to the copyright of both the video game itself and content that the user (consumer) might generate and add to the game. A recent ruling from a Paris court has determined that such terms in Valve’s Steam Subscriber Agreement, along with a number of other terms, were unfair according to French consumer protection laws and French copyright law. This decision has sparked some debate, as critics believe that this might hurt video game developer’s ability to sell copies of their works. While the application of the software directive to video games might seem obvious, it is important to note that several aspects of a videogame, such as graphics and sound, is excluded from this directive. A somewhat vaguely formulated stance on this was adopted in Nintendo vs PC Box by the CJEU, in which it appears that video games as a whole are only protected by the InfoSoc directive. Even more recent case law suggests that digital content sold through online downloads is not considered a distribution in the eyes of the InfoSoc directive and thus no consumptions of rights happen. This paper concludes that a term, which specifies that a videogame is a license rather than a sale, and thus unable to be legally resold, is unlikely to be considered unfair, with respects to the unfair terms directive, provided it only pertains to online sales. The current regime of EU copyright law does not allow for an interpretation in which a physical sale of a videogame does not constitute a distribution with regards to the InfoSoc directive. Furthermore it concludes that, while a transfer of rights or a perpetual license to user generated content without any remuneration for its creator is not prohibited, it is likely to be considered unfair as it provides a significant imbalance between the two parties.
Emneord
Kolofon: Denne side er en del af AAU Studenterprojekter — Aalborg Universitets studenterprojektportal. Her kan du finde og downloade offentligt tilgængelige kandidatspecialer og masterprojekter fra hele universitetet fra 2008 og frem. Studenterprojekter fra før 2008 kan findes i trykt form på Aalborg Universitetsbibliotek.
Har du spørgsmål til AAU Studenterprojekter eller Aalborg Universitets forskningsregistrering, formidling og analyse, er du altid velkommen til at kontakte VBN-teamet. Du kan også læse mere i AAU Studenterprojekter FAQ.